top of page
  • Ben Beck

Tips for Dealing with a Lemon Car Dealership

Every year, thousands of consumers face the distressing experience of buying a car that turns out to be a 'lemon.' In vehicle terms, a lemon refers to a new or used vehicle that has one or more manufacturing or design defects that significantly impair its use, safety, or value. As a buyer, dealing with repeated breakdowns, constant repairs, and ultimately, an unsafe defective vehicle can be incredibly frustrating.

Have you got a good tip for dealing with a lemon car dealership? In this blog we will explore how the state's lemon laws can help you avoid buying a lemon.

Navigating the automotive industry, particularly when it comes to lemon car dealerships, can be complex and somewhat intimidating. However, knowledge is power. This blog aims to arm you with essential tips and strategies to deal with lemon car dealerships effectively, from recognizing potential lemon cars and interacting with dealerships to asserting your rights under state lemon laws.

Understanding Lemon Laws

Lemon laws have been established to protect consumers from faulty vehicles that fail to meet the expected standards of performance and quality. The origins of lemon laws can be traced back to the mid-20th century, as an offshoot of consumer protection laws. Their primary function is to hold manufacturers and car dealers accountable for selling defective motor vehicles.

State Lemon Laws Vary

Each state in the U.S. has its own lemon laws, with various stipulations on what qualifies as a lemon. Although they are similar, they are not the same and the differences are hugely important to a lemon law claim. Do not assume that you have the same deadlines, requirements or entitlements as your out-of-state friends or relatives that bought a lemon.

These laws are pivotal as they provide a recourse for consumers who find themselves stuck with a lemon car. They often stipulate that the manufacturer must either replace the defective vehicle or refund the consumer, ensuring that the buyer isn't left at a loss.

However, it is important to remember that lemon laws are not a blanket cover. There are certain criteria your vehicle and situation must meet to qualify for protection under these laws. This underscores the importance of thoroughly understanding your state's lemon law and being aware of your rights as a consumer.

What Sets California's Lemon Laws Apart?

While all states in the U.S. have enacted some version of the lemon law, California's Lemon Law, officially known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is particularly robust and consumer-friendly and it is widely acknowledged as one of the most comprehensive lemon laws in the country. Here are a few distinctive features:

  1. Broad Coverage: The California Lemon Law applies to both new and used vehicles, as long as they are still under a manufacturer's warranty. This includes purchased and leased cars, trucks, SUVs, and some motorhomes and motorcycles.

  2. Inclusion of Used Vehicles: Unlike many states, California's lemon law also applies to used cars that are still under a manufacturer's or dealer's warranty. This broadens the umbrella of protection to more consumers.

  3. Strong Consumer Protection: The law requires the manufacturer to either replace the defective vehicle or refund the purchase price if the vehicle can't be repaired after a reasonable number of attempts. It also mandates the manufacturer to pay for the consumer's legal fees if the consumer prevails in a lemon law claim.

  4. Definition of 'Reasonable Attempts': California Lemon Law does not provide a clear definition of what constitutes a reasonable number of attempts to repair a vehicle but if the vehicle has been in the shop for more than 30 days (not necessarily consecutively) for warranty repairs, or if the same problem has been attempted to be repaired 2 or more times without success, it can be considered a lemon.

By setting a high standard of consumer protection, the California Lemon Law provides substantial assurance to consumers and holds manufacturers to a higher level of accountability.

Recognizing a Lemon Vehicle

Understanding what constitutes a lemon car is the first step in avoiding or dealing with a lemon car dealership. Here are some signs to look out for:

  • Persistent Mechanical Issues: This is the most telling sign. If your car experiences repeated problems that require constant repairs, particularly for the same issue, it might be a lemon.

  • Significant Time in Repair: If your new vehicle spends an excessive amount of time in the repair shop rather than on the road, this could be a red flag.

  • Recalls: Frequent recalls by the manufacturer for defects can indicate that the vehicle might be a lemon. It is crucial to keep an eye on manufacturer recalls.

  • Safety Issues: If the car has defects that could potentially compromise your safety or the safety of others, it could be considered a lemon. These could include issues with brakes, the engine, steering, or airbags.

  • Decreased Performance: If the car's performance is significantly lower than what was promised or expected, you might have a lemon on your hands.

Top Tip!

One of the best defenses against lemon vehicles is a pre-purchase inspection. This involves having a qualified, independent mechanic inspect the car before you purchase it. They can identify potential issues that could turn your new vehicle into a costly headache down the line. It's a small investment that could save you from the hassles of dealing with a lemon car.

By looking at the Vehicle Identification Number, vehicle history report and technical service bulletins, or spotting a sticker from the Certified Automotive Parts Association (CAPA) on a body panel means the part has been replaced, and an independent mechanic can spot these lemon red flags.

Tips on Interacting with Car Dealerships

When it comes to purchasing a vehicle, the interaction with the car dealership can significantly impact your experience and the outcome. Here are a few tips to ensure you are prepared and informed:

  1. Identify Dealership Red Flags If a dealership is reluctant to provide comprehensive information about a vehicle's history, rushes you through the purchasing process, or refuses to put verbal promises in writing, these are red flags. A reputable dealership should be transparent and professional in its dealings.

  2. Get Everything in Writing Always insist that any promises, statements about the condition of the car, or warranty coverage are put in writing. Verbal promises are harder to enforce and can lead to grey areas and misunderstandings later on.

  3. Ask the Right Questions Don't hesitate to ask detailed questions about the vehicle's history, previous ownership, any known defects, or repairs. Also, inquire about the return policy and warranty details.

  4. Take Your Time Don't let the dealership pressure you into making a quick decision. Take your time to research the vehicle, compare prices, read reviews, and thoroughly inspect the car before purchase.

  5. Conduct a Pre-Purchase Inspection If possible, arrange for a pre-purchase inspection by a trusted, independent mechanic. This can reveal potential issues that may not be apparent during a test drive. A professional mechanic will use the vehicle's identification number, vehicle history and other markers to see if you have a reliable car.

  6. Review the Contract Thoroughly Before signing, make sure you thoroughly understand the contract, including the fine print. If there are terms you don't understand, ask for clarification.

Dealing with car dealerships can become a daunting experience, but with proper preparation, knowledge, and a healthy dose of scepticism, you can protect yourself against potential lemons.

By looking at the Vehicle Identification Number, vehicle history report and technical service bulletins, or spotting a sticker from the Certified Automotive Parts Association (CAPA) on a body panel means the part has been replaced, and an independent mechanic can spot these lemon red flags.

Steps to Take When You Suspect You've Bought a Lemon

Realizing that you might have purchased a lemon can be a stressful experience. However, it's essential to take prompt and precise action. Here are the steps you should take if you suspect your new car is a lemon:

  1. Document Everything: Start keeping a detailed record of all issues, including dates, the nature of the problem, and any repairs or attempts at repair. This will serve as crucial evidence if you need to take legal action later.

  2. Report the Problem: Notify the dealership and the manufacturer in writing about the issues as soon as they arise. Be sure to include all relevant details about the problem and request for it to be fixed under warranty.

  3. Give the Dealer a Chance to Fix the Problem: Lemon laws typically require that you give the dealer a reasonable number of attempts to fix the issue before the vehicle can be considered a lemon.

  4. Maintain All Repair Records and Receipts: Keep all documents related to the repairs, including work orders and invoices. These provide a paper trail of the efforts to fix the vehicle and the duration it has been out of service.

  5. Start a Logbook: Record all interactions with the dealer and manufacturer, including phone calls, emails, and in-person meetings. Note down dates, names of the people you interacted with, and what was discussed or agreed upon.

  6. Check Your State's Lemon Law: As we have already noted, lemon laws can vary by state, such as criteria on the number of repair attempts, or the number of days the vehicle is out of service. Verify whether your vehicle meets these conditions.

  7. Consult a Lemon Law Attorney: If the issue isn't resolved after several attempts, or if the dealer or manufacturer is unresponsive, it may be time to consult with a lemon law attorney. They can guide you through the process and help you understand your rights and potential remedies under your state's Lemon Law.

Understanding Your Rights as a Consumer

As a consumer, it is paramount to understand the rights you possess under the Lemon Laws to protect yourself from defective vehicles and the tactics of car dealers or manufacturers.

Here is a basic outline of your rights:

  1. Right to a Functioning Vehicle: When you purchase a new or used car that is still under warranty, you have a right to expect that the vehicle will function as intended and as promised by the dealer or manufacturer.

  2. Right to Repairs: If the vehicle turns out to be defective, you have the right to request the dealership or manufacturer to have the vehicle inspected and to repair the defects under warranty.

  3. Right to a Refund or Replacement: If the dealership or manufacturer is unable to repair the vehicle after a reasonable number of attempts, or if the vehicle is out of service for a certain period due to repairs, you are typically entitled to a refund or a replacement vehicle under the lemon law.

  4. Right to Legal Recourse: If the dealership or manufacturer does not honor the terms of the warranty, you have the right to seek legal recourse. This could involve filing a lawsuit under the lemon law.

  5. Right to Legal Representation: You have the right to hire an attorney to represent you in a lemon law case. In many states, if you win the case, the dealer or manufacturer is required to pay for your attorney's fees.

  6. Right to Fair Treatment: You have the right to fair and honest treatment by the dealer and manufacturer. This includes providing accurate information about the vehicle and honoring the terms of the warranty.

When to Get a Lemon Law Attorney Involved

Navigating the complexities of lemon law can be challenging for the average car owner. That is precisely where a Lemon Law attorney can provide invaluable assistance. Here are some scenarios when you should consider getting a Lemon Law attorney involved:

  1. Multiple Failed Repair Attempts: If your vehicle has undergone several repair attempts for the same issue and the problem persists, it is time to consider legal help.

  2. Significant Time in Repair: If your car has been in the shop for an extended period for warranty repairs, and you are not getting satisfactory answers or solutions from the dealer or manufacturer, you may need an attorney.

  3. Denied Claims: If you have submitted a claim stating that your vehicle is a lemon and the manufacturer or dealer denies it, a Lemon Law attorney can help challenge this status quo.

  4. Ignored or Delayed Response: If the dealership or manufacturer is unresponsive, delaying action, or generally not cooperative in addressing your issues, an attorney can help expedite the process and advocate for your rights.

  5. Complex Process: If you find the process too complex to navigate on your own, or if you are unsure of your rights, always consult a Lemon Law attorney. They can guide you through the process, ensuring all necessary steps are correctly taken.

  6. Settlement Offers: If the dealer or manufacturer offers a settlement, an attorney can help you evaluate whether it is fair and what you are legally entitled to. In many cases, initial settlement offers from car dealers and manufacturers may not fully compensate you for your troubles.


Remember, while hiring an attorney may seem like a significant step, in many cases, if your claim is successful, the manufacturer may be required to cover your attorney fees. At the end of the day, the aim is to protect your rights and ensure that you get the justice you deserve.

The Beck Law Office Can Help You

If you find yourself dealing with a potential lemon car and the related complexities, don't face it alone. At the Beck Law Office, we specialize in lemon law cases and are dedicated to helping our customers navigate through this process. We understand the frustration of dealing with a lemon and we will work tirelessly to ensure your rights as a consumer are protected.

We are a reputable California-based lemon law firm with over a decade of experience in successfully representing clients in lemon law cases and proudly serving the state of California including Los Angeles, San Francisco, Santa Monica, Riverside, and other cities throughout the state.

Get in Touch Today

Whether it's a consultation, legal advice, or representation you need, our team of experienced attorneys is here to help. With our extensive knowledge of the intricacies of lemon laws, we are well-equipped to ensure that you get the justice you deserve.

Don't let a lemon sour your life. Take action now!

Visit our website today and learn more about how we can assist you, or schedule a free consultation with us. We would be delighted to help you.

bottom of page