top of page
  • Ben Beck

The Financial Repercussions of Owning a Lemon

Did you know that nearly 150,000 cars sold in California each year are considered lemons? These vehicles, plagued with repeated defects and issues, can turn the dream of car ownership into a financial nightmare. In California, a 'lemon' refers to a new or used vehicle that has significant, repeated problems not resolved even after a reasonable number of repair attempts by the manufacturer or its authorized dealers.

Owning a lemon car can have profound financial repercussions, from mounting repair bills to lost productivity and even legal expenses.

In this blog, learn what the financial repercussions of owning a lemon are.

In this blog, we will discuss the immediate and long-term financial impacts of owning a lemon vehicle in California. By understanding these repercussions, car owners can better navigate the challenges and make an informed decision to protect their finances.

What is the California Lemon Law?

The California Lemon Law, officially known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease new or used vehicles that fail to meet quality and performance standards. Enacted to hold manufacturers accountable, this law ensures that car owners are not left with defective vehicles that compromise their safety and financial stability. Under the Lemon Law, manufacturers are obligated to repair, replace or offer a full refund of the purchase price of vehicles that cannot be fixed after a reasonable number of attempts.

California's lemon law covers any new vehicle and extends to any defective used car still under warranty. Understanding your warranty and your state's lemon law before pursuing a lemon law claim is important.

Criteria for a Lemon

To qualify as a lemon, a vehicle must meet specific criteria:

  • Repeated Repair Attempts: The car must have undergone multiple repair attempts (typically two or more) for the same issue without a successful resolution. Alternatively, if the defect is serious enough to potentially cause death or severe injury, the manufacturer is presumed to have had a reasonable number of chances to repair it if it has had two failed repair attempts.

  • Significant Safety Issues: The defect must substantially impair the use, value or safety of the vehicle. This can include major mechanical failures (such as a brake failure), electrical problems or safety system malfunctions.

  • Warrantable Repair: The vehicle must have been out of service for a defect that was covered under the warranty. Maintenance and non-warranty repairs are not covered.

Your Legal Rights

Lemon Laws ensure that consumers are not financially burdened by a defective car and provide a clear course of action to seek justice and compensation. However, even with these legal protections, the financial repercussions of owning a lemon can be significant.

1. Immediate Financial Costs

➡️ Repair Expenses

One of the most immediate and tangible financial burdens of owning a lemon car is the cost of repeated repairs. Despite manufacturers' obligations under the Lemon Law, the process of identifying and attempting to fix the defect often incurs significant out-of-pocket expenses. These can include labor costs, parts, diagnostic fees and potential secondary repairs due to ongoing issues. Even if some repair costs are covered under warranty, incidental expenses such as transportation while the car is in the repair shop and towing the car to the dealership can add up quickly.

➡️ Lost Time and Productivity

The financial impact of owning a lemon goes beyond just repair costs. Time lost dealing with a defective vehicle can result in decreased productivity and missed workdays, leading to potential loss of income. Every trip to the mechanic or dealership requires taking time off from work or other responsibilities. Additionally, frequent repairs can disrupt daily routines and cause stress, further affecting one's ability to focus and perform effectively at work. Over time, these lost hours while having your vehicle repaired, can translate into significant financial losses, particularly for individuals with hourly wages or those who rely on their vehicles for their livelihood.

➡️ Rental Car Costs

While a lemon car is being repaired, or waiting for a replacement, vehicle owners often need an alternative mode of transportation. This can lead to the additional expense of renting a car. For longer repair durations, these expenses can become a considerable financial burden, and while some manufacturers cover rental costs under warranty, this is not always guaranteed.

2. Long-term Financial Consequences

➡️ Depreciation

One of the most significant long-term financial consequences of owning a lemon car is accelerated depreciation. Vehicles classified as lemons typically depreciate much faster. This rapid loss in value is due to the persistent mechanical issues and the stigma associated with a car that has been repeatedly repaired. Potential buyers are often wary of purchasing a car with a history of problems, even if those issues have been addressed.

➡️ Insurance Premiums

Owning a lemon can also impact insurance premiums and coverage. A car with a history of defects and repairs may be deemed higher risk, leading to increased insurance rates. Additionally, if the car has been involved in accidents due to its defects, this can further raise premiums. In some cases, insurers may limit coverage options or refuse to insure the vehicle altogether, forcing the owner to seek more expensive or less comprehensive insurance policies.

➡️ Loan and Lease Obligations

Continuing to make loan or lease payments on a non-functional vehicle is another significant financial burden for owners of lemon cars. When a car is frequently out of service, the owner still must meet their financial obligations, including monthly payments. This situation is particularly challenging if the car's defects render it unusable for extended periods. Owners may find themselves paying for a vehicle they cannot drive, creating a frustrating and financially draining scenario.

3. Legal Fees

Pursuing a lemon law case in California often involves hiring an attorney who specializes in consumer protection and lemon law cases. While many lemon law attorneys work on a contingency fee basis—meaning they only get paid if you win the case—there are still potential costs to consider. By working with an experienced lemon law attorney, you can better navigate the legal process and potentially mitigate some of the financial burdens associated with owning a lemon vehicle.

4. Psychological Costs

➡️ Stress and Anxiety

Dealing with a defective vehicle often means frequent trips to the mechanic, uncertainty about the car’s reliability and the looming fear of potential breakdowns. This ongoing stress can take a toll on mental health, leading to anxiety and frustration. The worry about safety, financial strain from repair costs, and the inconvenience of dealing with an unreliable vehicle can create a persistent sense of unease.

➡️ Impact on Daily Life

Frequent repairs and car issues can severely disrupt daily routines and family life. Dependable transportation is crucial for commuting to work, running errands and fulfilling family responsibilities. Missed workdays, cancelled appointments and the need to arrange alternative transportation can create logistical challenges.

Understanding these costs is crucial for car owners as they navigate the challenges of owning a lemon and seek appropriate remedies to mitigate their financial and emotional losses.

Strategies for Mitigation

➡️ Documentation

One of the most effective strategies for mitigating the financial and emotional impacts of owning a lemon car is to maintain meticulous documentation. Keeping detailed records of all repairs, communications and transactions related to the vehicle is crucial. This includes:

  • Repair Records: Document each repair attempt, including dates, descriptions of the problems and the work performed by the mechanic or dealership. Ensure you obtain and save all repair orders and receipts.

  • Communications: Keep a log of all communications with the manufacturer, dealership, and repair shop. This includes emails, letters and phone call summaries. Recording dates, names of individuals spoken to and the content of the conversations can be invaluable.

  • Vehicle History: Maintain a comprehensive history of the vehicle, noting any recurring issues and previous ownership if applicable.

This thorough documentation can strengthen your case if you need to pursue a lemon law claim, providing clear evidence of the vehicle’s defects and the attempts to repair them.

➡️ Consumer Awareness

Preventing the purchase of a lemon car starts with thorough research and awareness. Consumers can take several steps to reduce the risk of buying a defective vehicle:

  • Research Vehicle Models: Before purchasing, research the reliability and performance history of the vehicle model you’re interested in. Look for reviews, consumer reports, and recall information.

  • Check Vehicle History Reports: For used cars, obtain a vehicle history report through services like Carfax or AutoCheck. This report can reveal past accidents, repairs, and ownership history.

  • Inspect and Test Drive: Always inspect the vehicle thoroughly and take it for a test drive. Pay attention to any unusual sounds, performance issues, or warning lights.

  • Professional Inspection: Consider having the vehicle inspected by an independent mechanic before purchase, especially for used cars. An expert can identify potential problems that may not be immediately apparent.

  • Understand the Warranty: Review the vehicle’s warranty coverage carefully to understand what repairs and issues are covered and for how long.

By taking these proactive steps, consumers can make more informed decisions and significantly reduce the likelihood of purchasing a lemon vehicle.

➡️ Seek Professional Legal Advice

Navigating a lemon law claim can be complex and challenging, especially for those unfamiliar with legal processes. Lemon laws vary by state and seeking professional legal assistance from lawyers who are well-versed in state laws can make a significant difference. A lawyer specializing in lemon law can:

  • Evaluate Your Case: Provide an informed assessment of whether your vehicle qualifies as a lemon under California law.

  • Guide You Through the Process: Help you understand your rights and the steps involved in filing a claim, ensuring you meet all necessary legal requirements.

  • Negotiate on Your Behalf: Communicate and negotiate with the manufacturer to seek a fair resolution, whether it’s a repair, replacement or refund.

  • Represent You in Court: If necessary, represent you in court to pursue your claim effectively.

Many lemon law attorneys, such as The Beck Law Office, work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you only pay if you win your case, making legal assistance more accessible.

If you think you may have a lemon on your hands, don't hesitate to contact us today. Let's fight for the compensation you deserve.


bottom of page