top of page
  • Ben Beck

What Happens if You Win a Lemon Law Case in California?

Navigating through the intricacies of California's Lemon Laws can be a daunting task, but understanding your rights and the processes involved is crucial for any consumer faced with a potentially defective vehicle.

California's Lemon Law is designed to protect consumers who have purchased or leased new vehicles that turn out to be defective, ensuring that they are not stuck with a 'lemon.' This law mandates that if a vehicle has a substantially impairing defect and cannot be repaired after a reasonable number of attempts, the manufacturer must either replace it or refund the consumer. The importance of this legislation cannot be overstated, as it provides a vital safeguard for consumer investments in new vehicles.

At The Beck Law Office, we specialize in California Lemon Laws, boasting years of experience and a track record of successful cases. Our expertise not only lies in representing our clients effectively but also in ensuring they are well informed about their rights and the legal proceedings involved.

Learn all you need to know about what happens if you win a lemon law case in California.

In this article, we outline a step-by-step guide on what to expect after winning a lemon law lawsuit in California. From understanding your compensation options, navigating the buyback or replacement vehicle process, and learning about how legal fees are handled, we have got you covered.

What Happens After Winning a Lemon Law Case?

Winning a lemon law case in California is a significant achievement that marks the end of a legal journey but also the beginning of a new phase where the verdict translates into tangible outcomes for the consumer. Understanding what happens at this juncture is crucial to successfully navigate the post-verdict process.

Understanding the Verdict

When you win a lemon law claim, the verdict essentially acknowledges that your vehicle is a lemon as defined by California law. But what does this mean for you as the consumer?

The verdict will specify the relief granted, which typically falls into two categories: a buyback (refund) or a replacement of the vehicle. The specific terms, such as the amount of the buyback or the details of the replacement, will be outlined in the verdict. It is essential to understand these terms clearly, as they dictate the next steps in your journey.

1. Vehicle Buyback Verdict:

A buyback verdict means the manufacturer is required to refund the purchase price of the vehicle and any expenditure the customer incurred for the purchase or lease of the car. This refund aims to restore the consumer financially to the position they were in before purchasing the lemon vehicle with certain deductions. The amount returned to you will encompass the entire contract purchase price of your vehicle, alongside incidental expenses and various collateral charges less certain deductions.

Here’s a detailed step-by-step guide on how the buyback process typically unfolds and what components are included in the buyback compensation.

Step 1: Verdict or Settlement Agreement

The buyback process commences once there is a verdict in favor of the consumer or a settlement agreement is reached between the consumer and the manufacturer.

Step 2: Calculating the Buyback Amount

The buyback amount is calculated based on the original purchase price of the vehicle and certain expenses incurred. This includes the following:

  • Sales Tax and Finance Charges: The refund will cover all the sales tax paid at the time of purchase, as well as any finance charges accrued over the ownership period, and any other government or mandatory charges incurred at the time of purchase.

  • License and Registration Fees (plus interest): Costs related to licensing and the interest paid on the vehicle loan will also be part of the refund package.

  • Repair Costs and Manufacturer Add-ons: If you incurred expenses for repairs or opted for additional features from the manufacturer, these costs would be reimbursed.

  • Incidental and Collateral Costs: Any other expenses that arose due to the vehicle being a lemon, such as rental car costs, storage fees, ride share expenses, registration renewals, or towing charges, are also considered for reimbursement.

Step 3: Deducting Usage Fee

A usage fee may be deducted from the buyback amount. This fee is calculated based on the mileage at which the first lemon law-related complaint was made, relative to a state-specific.

The formula for calculating this deduction is typically stipulated by state lemon laws and ensures that the consumer pays for the value of the vehicle usage before the defect has become apparent.

Step 4: Handling of Loan or Lease

If the vehicle was financed or leased, the buyback process includes paying off the outstanding loan or lease balance to the financier or lessor.

Consumers will receive the remainder of the buyback amount after the loan or lease balance has been settled.

Step 5: Vehicle Return and Payment

The consumer will return the vehicle to the manufacturer or a designated location.

Once the vehicle is returned, the buyback amount is paid to the consumer, completing the buyback process.

Step 6: Release of Liability

Upon completion of the buyback, the consumer will sign documents to transfer the vehicle's ownership back to the manufacturer, releasing the consumer from any further liabilities associated with the vehicle.

2. Vehicle Replacement Verdict:

In the case of a replacement verdict, the manufacturer is required to provide a replacement vehicle that is identical or substantially similar to the original one with the same or similar mileage to the mileage when the defect was first presented to the dealership on the lemon vehicle. This process involves several key aspects:

  • Vehicle Comparability: The replacement vehicle should match the original vehicle's make, model and specifications as closely as possible. If the exact model is no longer available, a comparable current model should be provided.

  • Manufacturer's Concessions: Sometimes, manufacturers may offer additional concessions to compensate for the inconvenience or to account for any differences between the original and replacement vehicles.

  • Transfer of Terms: The terms of the original purchase or lease, such as warranty coverage, should transfer to the replacement vehicle to ensure the consumer is not at a disadvantage.

  • Consumer Responsibilities: The consumer might be responsible for any usage fee or mileage deduction as defined by state lemon laws, which is calculated based on the usage of the original vehicle before the defect was reported.

Here's how the vehicle replacement process typically works and what consumers should be aware of regarding potential costs.

Step 1: Understanding Vehicle Replacement

  • Eligibility: First, it is determined whether the consumer is eligible for a replacement based on the specifics of their case and the applicable lemon law provisions.

  • Equivalence: The replacement vehicle should be identical or substantially similar to the original vehicle. This includes the make, model, year, and any options or packages initially purchased.

Step 2: Selection Process

  • Manufacturer's Role: The manufacturer will typically provide the replacement vehicle with the same make and model. The consumer may have the opportunity to inspect and approve the vehicle before finalizing the replacement.

  • Model Year: Depending on availability, the replacement vehicle might be a newer model year than the original.

  • Options and Upgrades: If the exact model or specifications are not available, the manufacturer should provide a vehicle with comparable or superior options.

Step 3: Potential Costs

  • Difference in Value: If there's a difference in value between the original and the replacement vehicle, especially if the replacement is of greater value, the consumer might need to negotiate or pay the difference.

  • Incidental Costs: The consumer should not be responsible for any costs directly associated with the replacement process, but it is crucial to clarify this with the manufacturer or through legal counsel.

Step 4: Finalizing the Replacement

  • Documentation: The consumer will need to complete all necessary paperwork, transferring ownership of the replacement vehicle while returning the lemon vehicle to the manufacturer.

  • Warranty: The replacement vehicle typically comes with the manufacturer's warranty.

Vehicle warranty is key to lemon law lawsuits. It is advisable to have the legal support of an experienced lemon law attorney during the lemon law process to ensure all terms are fair and in compliance with state lemon laws.

Both refund and replacement lemon law settlement verdicts are designed to ensure that the consumer is made whole after experiencing a lemon law issue, with protections in place to ensure they are not financially disadvantaged by the defective vehicle experience.

It is advisable to have the legal support of an experienced lemon law attorney during the lemon law process to ensure all terms are fair and in compliance with state lemon laws.

Legal Fees and Costs in Lemon Law Cases

In lemon law cases, understanding who bears the legal costs is crucial for clients. Here's an overview of how attorney's fees and costs are typically handled in these situations:

Who Pays the Attorney Fees?

In California, if you win your lemon law case, the manufacturer is required to cover your attorney's fees and legal costs. This provision encourages consumers to seek legal representation without the fear of incurring prohibitive costs.

The law's design ensures that consumers can assert their rights against manufacturers without the financial burden falling on them. It levels the playing field, given that manufacturers have significant legal resources at their disposal.

Why Choose The Beck Law Office to Represent You in a Lemon Law Lawsuit?

When you choose The Beck Law Office to represent you, you are benefiting from over a decade of specialized expertise in lemon law lawsuits and a proven track record in this field. We offer a client-centric approach with no upfront costs, emphasizing transparent communication and comprehensive support throughout your case.

At The Beck Law Office, we operate on a contingency fee basis. This means that our clients do not pay upfront legal fees or out-of-pocket expenses during the case. Our fees are contingent upon winning the case; if we successfully resolve your lemon law claim, our fees are then paid by the manufacturer as part of the case settlement or verdict.

Our dedication to advocating for our customers' rights and ensuring they receive the compensation they deserve makes us a trusted partner in navigating the complexities of lemon law claims.

Contact us today for a free initial consultation and let us help you in reaching a fair resolution without the worry of legal expenses.


bottom of page