top of page
  • Ben Beck

The Perils of Class Actions in California Lemon Law

The Perils of Class Actions in California Lemon Law

The California lemon law, also known as the Song-Beverly Act, is a powerful tool for consumers who have purchased a defective vehicle with an underlying issue. It allows them to seek a refund or replacement vehicle if the manufacturer is unable to repair the defects after several repair attempts, and it offers legal protection to consumers to seek compensation for their lemon vehicle and recover any damages and expenses incurred by the vehicle manufacturer or dealership.

If you suspect you may have ended up with a lemon car, contact a reputable lemon law attorney immediately who can offer you a free consultation and advice on whether to take legal action, open an individual lemon law case, and even talk you through the advantages and disadvantages of a class action settlement.

What is a Lemon Vehicle?

A lemon car in a lemon law case can be described as a vehicle that has a significant defect that seriously compromises the vehicle's safety, value, and intended purpose, making it unsafe to drive and even risking serious injury. Examples of lemon vehicles can include non-working or faulty breaks, transmission or engine problems, defective airbags, lights, and a range of other mechanical issues.

What Are Lemon Law Class Actions?

A class action is a legal proceeding in which a group of people (typically 40 or more) with similar claims against a defendant can join together to seek relief. In the context of the California lemon law, a class action allows a group of consumers who have purchased a defective vehicle from the same manufacturer to join together and seek relief (usually in the form of warranty extensions, service coupons, or discounted service for the defective component parts).

In a class action lawsuit, the plaintiffs are referred to as the "class," and they are represented by a "class representative", also known as the lead plaintiff, who brings the lawsuit on behalf of the class. The class representative must have claims that are similar to the claims of the other members of the class. For example, if a group of consumers has purchased defective vehicles from the same manufacturer, they can join together in a class action to seek relief under the lemon law.

What is a Class Representative?

The role of the class representative is to act as the lead plaintiff in the lawsuit and to work with the attorneys to prosecute the lemon law case. This includes participating in discovery, attending court hearings, and negotiating settlements or judgments. The class representative is also responsible for communicating with the other members of the class and keeping them informed about the progress of the case.

Being a lead plaintiff in a class action lawsuit is a significant responsibility and requires a high level of commitment and dedication. It's important for consumers who are considering joining a class action lawsuit to be aware of the responsibilities of lead plaintiffs and to have confidence that the lead plaintiffs will represent their interests effectively.

Being a class representative is a voluntary role and it is important to note that the class representative is not compensated for their time or effort. However, they may be entitled to an incentive award, which is a separate payment made for serving as the lead plaintiff in the case. This award is intended to compensate the class representative for their time and effort in representing the class and is subject to court approval.

Who Selects the Class Representative?

The selection of the class representative is typically done by the court, or by the attorneys representing the class. The court will usually select a class representative who has the strongest claim and who is most likely to represent the interests of the class effectively. In some cases, the court may appoint more than one class representative, in order to ensure that the interests of all the members of the class are represented.

Adequacy of Representation

When it comes to selecting a class representative, both the lead plaintiff and the class action lemon law attorneys need to demonstrate that they will do their level best to fairly protect the interest of every single individual within the class. The class representative needs to possess sufficient integrity and credibility to convince the court that they have no conflict of interest with the other individuals within the class and that they will sincerely perform any fiduciary duties required to represent the class through their lemon law attorney. Furthermore, the Class Counsel needs to be selected from experienced lemon law attorneys who are competent to conduct lemon law litigation without any conflicts of interest.

The Responsibilities of a Lead Plaintiff

In a class action lawsuit, the lead plaintiffs, or class representatives, are responsible to perform the fiduciary duties required to represent the interests of the class members. Their responsibilities include communicating with the class and acting as a liaison between the class and the attorneys representing the class. They work closely with the attorneys to gather evidence and build a strong case and provide valuable input on the strategy and direction of the case. They must follow the guidance and instructions of the court and must be willing to abide by the court's rules and procedures.

Individual Lemon Law Claim vs Class Action Settlement

In lemon law cases, when pursuing a claim, consumers have two options: an individual claim or a class action claim. Both options have their own advantages and disadvantages, and it's important for consumers to understand the differences between the two before deciding which one to pursue.

Individual Lemon Law Claims

Individual lemon law claims, also known as single-plaintiff claims, are legal proceedings in which a single consumer brings a claim against a manufacturer for a defect in a vehicle that is covered under the lemon law. In this type of claim, the consumer seeks relief for the damages caused by the defect, such as the costs of repairs, the diminished value of the vehicle, and any other costs, such as rental car costs or additional repairs incurred as a result of the defect.

One of the main advantages of an individual claim is that it allows the consumer to seek the full amount of damages that they are entitled to, without having to share the recovery with other plaintiffs. Additionally, individual claims can be resolved faster than class action claims, which can take years to resolve in some cases.

Class Action Lemon Law Claims

A class action lawsuit, on the other hand, is a legal proceeding in which a group of consumers with similar claims against a manufacturer join together to seek compensation. In this type of lemon law claim, the consumers, referred to as the "class," are represented by a "class representative" who brings the lawsuit on behalf of the class. The class representative must have claims that are similar to the claims of the other members of the class. For example, if a group of consumers has purchased the same model of car with defects, they can join together in a class action to seek damages for the breach of warranty by the car manufacturer.

Advantages of Lemon Law Class Actions

Class action lawsuits can be a powerful tool for consumers to seek compensation and hold companies accountable for their actions in selling defective or misleading goods. Here are a few examples of the advantages of class action lawsuits:

Holding Companies Accountable

Class action lawsuits allow a large number of consumers to join together and hold a company accountable for its actions. This can be particularly effective when the company has produced a large number of defective products or engaged in a pattern of illegal or unethical behavior.


Class action lawsuits can be more efficient than individual lawsuits. The class representative can negotiate with the company on behalf of the entire class, which can save time and resources for both the plaintiffs and the defendants.

Fair Compensation

Class action lawsuits can provide fair compensation for the damages suffered by the plaintiffs. The settlement or judgment amount can be large enough to provide meaningful compensation for all the plaintiffs, even if the recovery for each individual plaintiff is relatively small.

Deterrent Effect

Class action lawsuits can have a deterrent effect on companies, by making them aware that they will be held accountable for their actions and that they will have to pay for the damages caused to the consumers.

Access to Justice

These lawsuits can provide access to justice for consumers who might otherwise not have the time or resources to pursue an individual lawsuit. This is particularly important for consumers who have suffered small damages but individually would not be able to afford to bring a lawsuit.

Encourage Fair Business Practices

Class action lawsuits can be an effective way to encourage fair business practices and to enforce consumer protection laws, by making it more difficult and costly for companies to engage in illegal or unethical behavior.

Disadvantages of Class Action Lawsuits

It's important for consumers to understand the potential risks of class action lawsuits and weigh them against the potential benefits before deciding to participate in one. It is always important to consult with a legal professional to understand the process and the potential outcome and make an informed decision about whether to participate in a class action lawsuit or opt out and pursue an individual claim. While these lawsuits can be a powerful tool for consumers to seek damages and hold companies accountable, they also carry some risks that consumers should be aware of. Here are a few examples:

No Guarantee

There is no guarantee that the lawsuit will be successful or that you will receive monetary compensation as part of the class action settlement. The court must determine whether or not your case has merit, and even if it does, the opposing party may decide to reject any settlement offers.

Slow-moving Process

Class action lawsuits can take years to resolve, which can be frustrating for consumers who are stuck with a defective product or have suffered damages and want a resolution as soon as possible.

Limited Recovery for Individual Plaintiffs

In a class action, the recovery is distributed among all the plaintiffs, which means that each individual may receive only a small amount of compensation. This can be particularly disappointing for consumers who have suffered significant damages as a result of a defective product.

Giving up Certain Rights

In a class action, the plaintiff must agree to have their case decided by a judge or jury, rather than having a trial by a judge or jury individually. Additionally, the plaintiff gives up the right to appeal the case individually, and instead, the case can only be appealed as a group.

Attorney's Fees

Class actions also require the plaintiffs to hire a lemon law lawyer and pay legal fees, which can be costly. Lemon law attorney fees can add up quickly in these types of cases, and these fees can be taken out of the recovered amount, which can in some cases makes the recovery even less for individual plaintiffs. The court may decide to award attorneys’ fees in some cases, but this is not always the case.

Some class action lawsuits may have a contingency fee arrangement, which means that the attorney will not be paid if the case is lost. In these cases, the attorney will receive a percentage of the recovered amount if the case is successful.

Difficult to Opt-out

In some cases, the process of opting out of a class action can be complicated, and manufacturers can make it difficult for consumers to do so, by not providing enough information or by making the process difficult.

Limited Timeframe

Finally, there are often time limits associated with pursuing a claim under California lemon law. The deadline to join a class action lawsuit can come quickly and if you miss it, you may not be able to participate in the settlement or receive any compensation from it.

What are Lemon Law Subclasses?

In cases where some members of the class have separate interests from the rest of the class but are similar to a smaller group within the class, a subclass may be established with each subclass represented by its own class representative.

Manufacturers and Class Action

Manufacturers may suggest or agree to a class action lawsuit in certain situations, although it's important to note that they are not always the ones initiating the class action. Here are a few reasons why a manufacturer may suggest or agree to a class action lawsuit:

Cost savings

A class action lawsuit can be less expensive for a manufacturer to defend than multiple individual lawsuits. This is because the manufacturer only has to defend against the claims of the class, rather than the claims of each individual plaintiff. Additionally, the manufacturer can negotiate a settlement for the entire class, rather than having to negotiate separate settlements for each individual plaintiff.

Reduced Legal Risk

A class action can also reduce the legal risk for a manufacturer. In a class action, the manufacturer can agree to a settlement or judgment that provides relief for the entire class, rather than facing the possibility of multiple judgments that could be more severe.

Reputation Management

A class action lawsuit can also be a way for a manufacturer to manage their reputation. By settling a class action lawsuit, a manufacturer can show that it is willing to take responsibility for its actions and provide relief for the consumers who have been affected by its defective product. This can help to mitigate negative publicity and damage to the manufacturer's reputation.

Avoiding Negative Publicity

A class action lawsuit can also be a way for a manufacturer to avoid negative publicity. By settling a class action lawsuit, a manufacturer can avoid having to go to trial, which can be a long and public process.

Avoiding Individual Lawsuits

A manufacturer may suggest a class action lawsuit to avoid facing multiple individual lawsuits. In some cases, the manufacturer may prefer to settle a class action lawsuit to avoid the cost, time, and uncertainty associated with multiple individual lawsuits.

The Perils of Class Actions

Manufacturers and car dealers are aware of the loopholes surrounding lemon laws and they will try to use this to their advantage. Often, consumers are approached by the vehicle manufacturer to be part of a class action because it is less costly for the manufacturer to make a settlement offer this way than to pay out for an individual lemon law claim. This is often not in the customers' best interest and the manufacturers will try to convince them that they can not opt out of a class action notice.

What is a Class Action Notice?

A class action opt-in notice is a document that is provided to potential plaintiffs in a class action lawsuit, outlining the terms of the lawsuit and the rights of the plaintiffs. The opt-in notice informs potential plaintiffs of the opportunity to join the class action and to participate in any settlement or judgment. It's important to understand that not all class actions are opt-in, some are opt-out, meaning that the members of the class are automatically included in the action unless they take specific steps to exclude themselves.

Consumers need to carefully review the opt-in notice and understand the terms of the lawsuit and the rights of the plaintiffs before deciding to join the class action. It's also important to understand the opt-in deadline and to ensure that the necessary forms and documents are completed and submitted on time.

Examples of Famous Class Action Lawsuits

Here are a few examples of notable class action lawsuits that have been filed in the United States:

Toyota Motor Corp. Unintended Acceleration Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation

This class action lawsuit was filed against Toyota in 2010, alleging that the company's vehicles were prone to unintended acceleration, which caused accidents and injuries. The lawsuit was eventually settled for $1.6 billion, with Toyota agreeing to pay for the costs of repairs and compensation for those who were injured or lost loved ones in accidents involving unintended acceleration.

Ford Motor Company Dual Power Shift Transmission Class Action

This class action was filed against Ford Motor Company in 2012, alleging that the company's dual power shift (DPS) transmission shuddered, jerked, slipped, bucked, hesitated during gear changes, was prone to premature wear, suffered from delays downshifting or delays in accelerating. Internal emails revealed that Ford's engineers knew the transmission had defects before selling them to consumers resulting in thousands of dollars by consumers in repairs. Internal investigations showed that despite this knowledge, Ford declined to make permanent repairs because effective changes were too expensive. Ford acknowledged spending $47 million dollars repurchasing 2,666 Ford Fiestas and Focus vehicles but Ford has not disclosed what it paid out after 2019.

Why Choose The Beck Law Office to Represent You?

When considering choosing an attorney in lemon law claims, it is paramount to choose a trusted and reputable firm that has an extensive understanding of the state's laws and they are well versed in the loopholes and traps auto manufacturers and dealer often resort to with consumers.

Our reputable lemon law attorney firm has over a decade of experience in serving California and successfully applying lemon law protection to hundreds of claims. We proudly operate in and around Los Angeles, San Francisco, Santa Monica, Riverside, and the wider Golden State of California.

Our firm specializes in lemon law cases and we have extensive experience in representing our client's interests through litigation or negotiation of settlements. We work hard to ensure that our lemon law consumers win their cases, receive full refunds or replacements vehicles, and obtain any other appropriate compensation due to them. This high standard of consistency has earned us a reputation as one of the most trusted lemon law attorneys in California.

Our Promise To You

We pride ourselves on our excellent attorney-client relationship and we always go the extra mile for all our clients, ensuring that they receive the best possible outcome and the compensation they deserve.

Our skilled lawyers at The Beck Law Office have the expertise, experience, and competence to go toe-to-toe and represent you against some of the largest vehicle manufacturers and dealerships in California. You can have full confidence in our capability to succeed in your lemon law claim and represent you to the best of our ability.

Contact Us Today

If you require expert input in your lemon law claim, don't hesitate to contact us for a free consultation and a no-obligation case review. We will readily review your case and advise you of your legal options and discuss with you where California lemon law applies.

Let us help you get the justice you deserve in a quick, friendly, and efficient manner.


bottom of page