top of page
  • Ben Beck

How to Avoid Buying a Lemon Car

Buying a new car should be an exciting time; a day filled with the anticipation of driving off in a vehicle that is all yours, sparkling and new. However, it can also become an overwhelming experience because sadly, not every new car is a good buy. Some might have hidden defects that can lead to headaches and costly repairs down the road.

However, with a bit of knowledge and know-how, you can greatly reduce the risk of buying a lemon. This guide is here to help you navigate through the process, offering practical advice and insights to ensure that your new car day has a happy ending!

Learn how to avoid buying a lemon car by following some top tips about what to look for, negotiating with car dealerships, accessing the vehicle history report and more.

What is a Lemon Car?

The term 'lemon car' often conjures up the image of an unreliable, defective vehicle, but in reality, new cars can also fall into this category. A lemon car is essentially a new or used car that has significant manufacturing defects affecting its safety, value or use. These defects often persist despite multiple repair attempts. Understanding what constitutes a lemon is crucial, as it can save you from the frustration and financial burden associated with these troublesome vehicles.

In this article, we will provide some strategies and tips to guide you through the car-buying process, ensuring that you drive away with a reliable vehicle.

1. Research Before You Buy

Doing your homework before purchasing a new car is crucial. It helps you make an informed decision and avoid some potential pitfalls.

➡️ Car Models and Brands:

Every car model and brand has its unique set of strengths and weaknesses. Some models are known for their reliability and longevity, while others may have a history of mechanical issues or recalls.

  • Compare Models: Look at various car models within your interest range and compare their features.

  • Brand Reputation: Research the reputation of different car brands for reliability, customer service, and overall satisfaction.

  • Long-Term Performance: Consider factors like the car's long-term durability, maintenance costs and resale value.

➡️ Online Resources:

Online resources such as automotive review websites, forums and consumer reports are invaluable tools for prospective car buyers.

  • Expert Reviews: Read reviews from trusted automotive websites for professional insights.

  • Consumer Feedback: Check forums and customer reviews for real-world experiences and issues.

  • Common Issues: From factory defects to design flaws, it is essential to be aware of the common issues that new car models might face.

  • Recalls: Check if your car's make and model have been previously reported for any manufacturer defects, technical service bulletins, or recalls at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

2. Inspect the Vehicle

When buying a new car, a thorough inspection is just as important as it is for a used car. It is about ensuring that everything is in top condition and that there are no hidden surprises.

Here’s a quick breakdown of what to focus on:

  • Exterior Inspection: Check for any paint imperfections, scratches or dents. Ensure all panels align correctly and the doors, hood and trunk open and close smoothly.

  • Interior Inspection: Verify the functionality of all interior features, including lights, air conditioning, infotainment system and navigation. Inspect upholstery for any defects or damages.

  • Engine and Mechanical Parts: Look under the hood for any signs of leaks or damage. Check fluid levels (oil, coolant, brake fluid) to ensure they are filled to the correct levels.

  • Tire and Suspension Check: Inspect tires for proper inflation and even wear. Test the vehicle suspension by pushing down on each corner of the car to see if it settles back quickly.

  • Safety Features: Test all safety features like brakes, airbags, seat belts and any advanced driver-assistance systems.

3. Ask for a Professional Vehicle Inspection

A professional vehicle inspection is a critical step in ensuring the quality and reliability of your new car. It provides an expert opinion of the vehicle's condition, identifying potential issues that might not be immediately apparent to the untrained eye.

  • Expert Evaluation: A professional mechanic can provide an in-depth evaluation, identifying issues that might not be obvious. They can perform a comprehensive check, including engine diagnostics and electronic systems.

  • Peace of Mind: A professional inspection offers reassurance about the car’s condition. It is particularly advisable if you are buying a car that has been on display or used as a demo model.

4. Understand the Warranty

Understanding car warranties and their coverage is an essential aspect of purchasing a new car, as it can significantly impact your future expenses. Always read the fine print to ensure you are well-informed about your vehicle's protection and maintenance requirements.

  • Manufacturer’s Warranty: Understand the length of the warranty and what components are covered. Check if the warranty includes roadside assistance or free maintenance services.

  • Extended Warranties and Service Contracts: Consider if purchasing an extended warranty or service contract is beneficial for you. Understand the terms, what’s included, and what’s excluded.

  • Limitations and Voidance: Be aware of actions or modifications to the car that could void the warranty. Understand the warranty claim process and any required maintenance to keep the warranty valid.

5. Examine the Vehicle History Report

Particularly pertinent for used cars but even when buying a new car, it is wise to examine the vehicle history report. This can provide valuable insights that are not always apparent through a visual inspection or test drive.

Here’s what to focus on:

  • Manufacturing Details: Confirm that the car's specifications match the manufacturer's records. This includes checking the make, model, year and engine type.

  • Dealer and Service History: Look for any records of service or maintenance done by the car dealership. This can give you an idea of how well the car has been taken care of, even if it is new.

  • Recall Information: The report may reveal if the car was subject to any recalls. Knowing this can help you verify if the necessary repairs or replacements were made.

  • Warranty Status: Confirm the start date of the warranty and any services or repairs done under warranty. This helps ensure you are getting the full benefit of the manufacturer's warranty.

  • Damage or Repair History: For cars that have been on the lot for a while or were used as demo vehicles, check for any past damage or repairs. This is crucial to ensure you are not buying a car that has been repaired after a significant incident.

  • Ownership History: While the number of previous owners is usually a factor considered for used cars, it is also beneficial to be aware of this for new cars, especially if they have been used as demo or service vehicles.

  • Obtain Vehicle History: Visit the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS) website to get a vehicle's history report with title, insurance loss and salvage information. You will need your VIN (Vehicle Identification Number) for this.

6. Test Drive Before You Buy

Test driving provides real-world insights into the vehicle's performance.

Here are some quick tips for making the most of your test drive:

  • Prepare a Checklist: Before the test drive, make a list of the things you want to check, such as handling, braking and the ease of using the infotainment system.

  • Simulate Real Driving Conditions: Drive on different types of roads to get a feel for the car’s performance under various conditions. Test the car in scenarios similar to your daily driving routine.

  • Focus on Comfort and Features: Pay attention to the comfort of the seats, visibility, legroom and how intuitive the controls are. Check the ease of parking, reversing and manoeuvring in tight spaces.

7. Dealer Negotiations

Learning how to talk to car dealers can help avoid common pitfalls and secure the best deal for you.

  • Do Your Homework: Know the market value of the car and the average price it is selling for in your area. Be aware of current promotions or incentives that you can leverage.

  • Be Clear About Your Needs and Budget: Stick to what you need in a car and don’t get swayed by upselling tactics. Be firm about your budget to avoid being pushed into overspending.

  • Understand Financing and Extras: If financing through the dealer, compare their rates with other financial institutions. Be cautious about add-ons and extended warranties; understand their costs and benefits.

  • Take Time to Reflect: Don’t decide on the spot. Give yourself time to think about the test drive experience and the overall deal.

  • Seek Second Opinions: Discuss your potential purchase with trusted friends or family members, or seek advice from automotive forums.

  • Revisit Your Options: If you have any doubts, don’t hesitate to retest the car or explore other models or dealerships.

Lemon cars are sadly not uncommon. A used vehicle is usually associated with lemons but it can also happen to new vehicles.

By following these simple steps, you can make a well-informed decision that aligns with your needs and budget. Remember, buying a car is a significant investment, and taking the time to get it right is crucial.

8. Know Your Legal Rights

Understanding your legal rights, particularly regarding the lemon law, is a crucial aspect of the car-buying process. Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers from defective vehicles that fail to meet quality and performance standards.

Here’s a closer look at what you need to know about these laws:

  • Lemon Law Coverage: Lemon laws vary by state but generally cover new vehicles with serious defects affecting their use, safety or value. Some states, such as California, may also include used or leased vehicles under their lemon laws.

  • Criteria to Qualify as a Lemon: The vehicle must have a substantial defect covered by the warranty that occurred within a specific period or number of miles after purchase. The defect must be significant enough that it impairs the vehicle’s use, safety or value.

  • Reasonable Number of Repair Attempts: Lemon laws typically require that the manufacturer or car dealer has made a reasonable number of attempts to repair the defect. What qualifies as 'reasonable' can vary, but it usually means several attempts over a certain period.

  • Consumer Rights Under Lemon Law: If your vehicle is a lemon, you are usually entitled to a replacement or refund. This includes the cost of the vehicle, as well as other possible costs and fees.

  • Filing a Lemon Law Claim: If you believe your vehicle is a lemon, it is important to keep detailed records of all repairs and communications. Consider consulting with a lawyer specializing in lemon law to guide you through the process.

  • Time Frame for Action: Be aware of the time frame in which you need to report the issue and file a claim, as it varies by state.

  • Protection Beyond Lemon Law: Even if your car doesn’t qualify under the lemon law, other consumer protection laws may apply. These can offer recourse for issues like false advertising or breach of warranty.

Spare yourself the hassle of costly repair costs but doing some research about the car's history before purchasing it.

Knowing these aspects of lemon law empowers you as a consumer and can help ensure that your car-buying experience is a positive one. If you find yourself in a situation with a potential lemon, understanding your rights is the first step in resolving the issue effectively.

How The Beck Law Office Can Assist You

By understanding your legal rights and the importance of professional legal advice, you can better navigate the car-buying process


We at The Beck Law Office specialize in lemon law and consumer protection. Our experienced attorneys are deeply committed to helping clients who have encountered issues with their vehicles. With a focus on personalized service, we offer expert legal advice and representation, ensuring our clients understand their rights and the legal processes involved.

Contact Us Today

If you live in California and you are struggling with the challenges of a lemon vehicle, remember you are not alone.

By choosing The Beck Law Office as your legal partner, you gain access to a team of professionals dedicated to protecting your interests and helping you navigate the challenges of lemon law and consumer protection with confidence and ease.

Contact us today and let us help you turn your lemon experience into a success story.


bottom of page